Fractional CMO for supplement brands

Sell the habit,
not just the bottle.

I’m Monica Hacker, a fractional CMO for DTC supplement and wellness brands. Acquisition, subscription retention and compliant creative, with one senior person accountable for the number.

Part of my beauty and wellness practice. Based in New York and Miami.

A woman with slicked back hair and gold jewelry holding up a red gummy, with an amber jar with a gold lid in her other hand, on golden yellow
$808Krevenue, DTC watch brand
Huggies
8.8xonline orders, wellness brand
Stitch Fix
$72Kpre-order sales, 3.7x return
Summer Fridays
4.1xreturn on Meta spend
Centrust Bank

The real problem

In supplements, the P&L is decided at month three.

  • Churn hits at month two and three.
  • Claims get the ad account flagged.
  • The same customer gets bought twice.

I start with where subscribers cancel, and why.

Read the full breakdown

Almost every supplement brand runs the same play: subscribe and save on the first order, a big Meta budget, and creative that promises more than compliance allows. It works for a quarter. Then subscription churn at month two and three eats the margin, the ad account gets flagged for claims, and the brand is buying the same customer twice.

The brands that compound do three things differently. They sell a habit, not a bottle, so the product gets used and reordered. They build creative around what they can say and prove, so the account stays healthy. And they treat month one to three as the retention window it is, with a flow designed to get someone to feel the difference before the next charge.

So I start with the cohort curve. Where people cancel, why they cancel, and what the first thirty days look like. Then acquisition gets rebuilt to buy customers who stay, not customers who are cheap.

More on who I work with

A DTC supplement, gut health, sleep, beauty from within or sports nutrition brand, launching or scaling, with a product that works and a subscription base that leaks.

Usually there’s an agency or a small team running paid well enough and nobody senior looking at the cohorts. That’s the gap I fill.

This sits inside my beauty and wellness practice. Not sure where you stand? Start with a Growth Audit: $2,500, your findings in 5 days.

Worth a read: which supplement brands ChatGPT recommends.

Want proof? Here’s how I grew a luxury wellness brand’s online orders 8.8x.

A green supplement jar, a small vial and capsules on a stone ledge with linen and a coral hibiscus

What I run

How an
engagement
works.

See what’s included

Paid that stays in the lines. Meta, Google and TikTok structured for creative testing, with claims that pass review and still land. Budgets set against subscriber LTV, not first order ROAS.

Subscription that sticks. Onboarding, dosing and expectation setting in the first thirty days, cadence that matches real usage, and save flows that catch cancels before they happen.

Offers with honest economics. Bundles, starter kits and subscribe and save designed so the first order is profitable on its own and the second order is the default.

01

Paid that stays in the lines

Claims that pass review and still land.

02

Subscription that sticks

The first thirty days, built to keep them.

03

Offers with honest economics

A first order that’s profitable on its own.

How we can
work together.

01

Fractional CMO

Starting at $8,500/mo
A gold watch with a green dial on the top step of a forest green podium, with a gold lipstick, a perfume bottle and a jar lined up on the step below

Senior marketing leadership, without the full-time hire. You have a team, an agency, or neither. What's missing is someone senior who sets the priorities and owns the result.

4-month minimum · Review in month 3

What's included

  • A growth plan tied to revenue, not activity
  • Decisions made on margin and cash, not just ad metrics
  • Ownership across paid, retention and conversion
  • Where your budget should go, and where it shouldn't
  • Monthly business reviews with clear next moves
  • Direction for your team and agency partners
  • Bringing in specialists when the work calls for it

Scope and fee depend on your team and what you need from me. Ad spend, software and outside creative are separate.

02

Growth Audit

Most brands start here$2,500 · 5 days
A hand holding a magnifying glass over a jar of cream with a gold lid, beside a serum bottle, on golden yellow

A clear read on acquisition, subscription retention, creative compliance and the economics behind it.

Delivered in 5 days

What's included

  • Acquisition: what a subscriber costs by channel and how much rides on Meta
  • Cohorts: where subscribers cancel, month by month, and what it does to LTV
  • Onboarding: what happens in the first thirty days after the first order
  • Claims and creative: what your ads say, what they can say, and what converts

You walk away with a clear list of what to fix first.

04

AI Visibility Check

$2,500 · 5 days
A white sneaker on top of a cobalt blue marble run, with chrome spheres rolling down the connected ramps

Is ChatGPT recommending your brand? I test the questions your customers ask before they buy across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google’s AI answers. You’ll see where you show up, who gets recommended, and what I’d change first.

Delivered in 5 days

What's included

  • AI visibility report + competitor scorecard. See how often and how prominently you show up, how AI describes your brand, and how you compare with competitors.
  • 90-day content plan. Get three priorities based on what your buyers ask, from what to publish to which pages to update.
  • AI referral tracking in GA4. With access, I’ll set up a saved view for AI referrals and verify your main conversion.
  • Live strategy session. We’ll review the findings and decide what to tackle first.

How the check works →

All pricing is a starting point. After our call, I’ll put together a proposal around your goals, and we’ll shape the scope together.

Fair questions

What supplement brands ask me first.

All questions →

What does a fractional CMO do for a supplement brand?

Owns the growth number across paid, subscription retention, the site and email and SMS, leads whoever is doing the work, and reports on what is actually driving profitable revenue.

How much does a fractional CMO cost for a supplement brand?

From $8,500 a month, 4 month minimum, review at month 3. Paid acquisition on its own from $4,500 a month. A Growth Audit is $2,500, and it’s how most engagements kick off. Here’s how that compares to 20 other US providers.

How do you handle claims and compliance in supplement ads?

I build creative around what you can say and prove, and set up the account so one flagged ad doesn’t take the whole thing down. Your regulatory counsel signs off on the claims. I make sure the creative still converts inside them.

Why is my subscription churning at month two?

Usually one of three things: the customer never felt the difference, the cadence doesn’t match real usage, or the discount bought someone who was never going to stay. The audit tells you which.

Do you work with Amazon as well as DTC?

My focus is the DTC side, where you own the customer and the data. If Amazon is a meaningful channel I fold it into the plan and the reporting, but I don’t run Amazon ads as a standalone service.

Monica Hacker

Hi, I’m
Monica.

I started in fashion, not in a spreadsheet. Five years agency side, I kept seeing teams working in silos with no one owning the bigger picture. So I built Hacker House to be that owner.

I keep a small roster on purpose. When you work with me, you get me.

Book a call →Let’s talk about where you want to go.
Growth AuditFrom $2,500
Book a call →